Select Year :

Source: https://www.jonpeddie.com/reviews/mobile-workstation-comparison

 
Mobile workstation comparison
By Jon Peddie Research | October  3rd 2017

 

Four different machines

At Siggraph Dell announced a new Anniversary edition thin and light 5520 Precision mobile workstation in recognition of the brands 20-year contribution to the mobile space. While Dell was celebrating their 20th anniversary PNY took the occasion to throw their hat in the ring by introducing their first workstation product, the Prevail Pro P4000 & P3000 mobile workstations.

We had the opportunity to stack up the 20-year veteran against the new upstart this week, as well as others.

When evaluating a mobile workstation, from our point of view, we think the Pmark with weight (pounds) included is a very good base. But, there are (at least) two ways to use the Pmark.

First, letís review what goes into a Pmark: Price, Performance, Power, and in the case of a mobile device, Pounds.

The equation is pretty straight forward: 

Pmark

  1. One way to use it is to pick a performance number that favors your favorite product, and then use the published specifications.
  2. Another way is to run a battery of tests and take the average score., and use published specifications.
  3. A third method is to use an average score, measure the actual power being consumed during test.
  4. And lastly (for this litany) is to use number three above and include the weight of the power supply (PSU).
     

We will show you our results for item two, and four.

The machines
Many people will look at the following list and say thatís not a fair comparison, different CPUs, different GPUs, and different screen size. Yes, all true, but this is a comparison. There will always be variances in design and products, but these products are built for the same purpose, to provide the user with the best mobile workstation experience.

@XI Computerís PowerGo mobile workstation

For the performance tests, we ran ViewPerf 12.1, Cinebench R15, Passmark, and GeekBench 4. As you might expect, some machines did better in one test than another, however, the Dell 7710 did best in all tests except ViewPerf, an in that one the PNY P4000 did 22% better than the 7710 this was expected given the 7710ís larger form factor.

But, in terms of the Pmark, anyway you want to use it, once again the @Xi PowerGO 15/7 took the prize in specifications, while the Del 5510 won on measured results.
 

@XI Computerís PowerGo mobile workstation

Many reviewers will simply use ViewPerf for evaluating a workstation, and thatís what the consortiumís test was designed for. ViewPerf, developed and maintained by the Spec organization, is a tried and trusted series of tests that incorporates several real-world applications, and so it is not considered a simulated test, like the others.

ViewPerf uses Catiia, Creo, Maya, Siemens, and Solidworks, as well as a data set from MRI files, and energy.

Each one of those tests is given a unique score, and so if you are working in a specific field, like say CAD, then you can look at the Siemens or Catia results to judge how well the workstation you are considering might do on your data.

@XI Computerís PowerGo mobile workstation

For the purposes of calculating the Pmark, we took the average of those test scores for the ViewPerf entry in our overall average performance number. However, ViewPerf is an important enough test we thought its results should be shown separately.

Depending upon what your personal preferences are, one of these machines should satisfy you. Jon for example wants a lot of pixels, and no weight. The Dell 5520 is his choice. Alex likes a big high-resolution screen and isnít afraid of a little bulk, so he tends toward the Dell 7710. Iím a power freak and for me the PNY is the best choice, while Kathleen thinks the @Xi is the coolest looking, well performing machine. Notice, none of us put price even in the equation. Generally speaking we donít think many users of professional workstations, especially mobile units put price very high on their list.   

What do we think?
The machines have a mix of Xeon and I7 CPUs, and this will probably be the last year weíll see that. With the introduction of the W series Xeon processors from Dell, workstation suppliers will be strongly discouraged from using an I7 as a workstation processor. Intel may even go so far as to punish such companies by denying marketing dollars.

 


 

 


 

 

DE Logo
 

 

 



 

Editors' Choice Awards - CNET

 


 

Editors' Choice Awards - CNET

 

 




ConnectPress

 

 


CADintentions

 

Social Media
Youtube

 

Twitter

 
Social Share:





@Xi Computer Corporation, 980 Calle Negocio, San Clemente, CA 92673, USA
1-800 432-0486 or (949) 498-0858 Fax: (949) 498-0257
Email - sales@xicomputer.com
trans.gif (43 bytes)
*Systems might be shown with optional equipment, including but not limited to: Monitors, upgraded case, speakers, ergonomic keyboard, upgraded mouse, HD-Trays, DVD-RW etc. Please check your actual order configuration. All sales, invoices & discounts are subject to final approval/verification by @Xi Computer. Estimated shipping date is approximate and is not guaranteed, actual shipping may vary as per our sales terms and conditions. Access to www.xicomputer.com is granted only by acceptance of Terms of Use Agreement
trans.gif (43 bytes)
Intel, the Intel logo, Intel Core, Intel Inside, the Intel Inside logo, Intel Xeon Phi, Xeon are trademarks of Intel Corporation in the U.S. and/or other countries.
E-Verify is a registered trademark of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. Xi , @Xi , the @Xi Logo, MTower, NetRAIDer, PowerGo, WebRAIDer, BladeRAIDer & Render-RT are trademarks and registered trademarks of @Xi Computer Corporation.
trans.gif (43 bytes)
Privacy & Terms Copyright © 1996, @Xi Computer Corporation.